Excellent warmth and keeps out the rain.

Bought a pair for my husband. After the first use the lining came loose on the right hand and came out with his fingers when he took them off. Totally annoying that every time he goes to put the gloves on he has to try to fit thumb and fingers into holes and try to force them into the proper finger and thumb slots. I do not recommend this product

My wife bought me these gloves. At first, I was happy with them. However, after using them a couple of times I found they stay wet inside after using them to shovel snow. And then they become smelly because they wouldn't dry in the inside. The last time I used them, I was taking them off and the inner liner stitching ripped from the glove. I can't put on the gloves because the liner is wadded up. I'm throwing them in the trash.

your hand sweats inside glove and difficult to get off or put back on.

I have three different pairs of Carhartt gloves and they all are terrible. They are hold moisture inside each finger therefore fingers become cold, and after having them on for a while and needing to take them off, they are nearly impassible to put back on because the inner lining within finger pulls out blocking ability to slide (or easily slide) back on. Plus, I went to put them on almost two weeks after using them during big winter storm here in northeast and the inside of the gloves were STILL moist.