Excellent gloves ! Super warm with or without the liner, you can also wear the liner by themselves.

If these would keep my finger tips warm after hours of snow blowing (and were properly sized) I'd rate them a 5. I purchased these from Meijer after mail ordering Carhartt gloves on line only to find them very undersized: SO ARE THESE. I wear a medium glove and I need XL in these and they are none too large! They are a good quality glove that goes on easily with or without the liner and fit about the same with or without the liner. Overall I like these glove and they are the warmest of all my Carhartt gloves and far better than competitor brands. I cannot recommend these or any Carhartt g;love for anyone who needs a larger than medium size glove, and these are the only model I will recommend . Very disappointed in Carhartt gloves I spent nearly $100 on 3 different pairs of Carhartt gloves this winter, and these are the best of those. All Carhartt gloves run very small in size.